My boyfriend doesn't like to go downtown to eat. (Yeah, I know!?), so when I want oysters, we go here. Only problem is they normally only have one or two kinds. I think having a sign that says "Oyster Bar" is a bit misleading.
That being said, we love the food here and go quite often. He normally gets the Coconut Shrimp, and I've tried just about everything. You know a place is good when you keep going back, and take friends there, and we do.
Casual place, we go early and have never needed reservations, as it has a bar side and restaurant side. We normally eat on the bar side.
Make sure to save room for the Peanut Butter Pie, it's divine!