Gotham seriously serves the best bagels outside of NY. I'd even say they're better than some bagel places on Long Island. These are real bagels, not the nonsense you get at the bagel chains (Einstein, Panera, Etc.). They are hard on the outside and chewy on the inside, exactly what a bagel should be. They don't come in blueberry, chocolate chip, or sunflower flavors. So, why only 4 stars and not 5? Well, not only are their bagels authentic NY style, but so are their employee's dispositions: surly. You won't find any smiles here.