I really heart this place. I've only ever been for lunch, but have tried just about every pizza on the menu and have yet to be disappointed.
The atmosphere is great - I'm a sucker for exposed brick and this place has an abundance of it. The upstairs location helps it feel a bit more intimate, and if you're by the window it's always fun to watch passers-by on 9th Ave. They also usually have fun music and/or projections on the walls, so there is no shortage of entertainment!
The pollo pesto pizza is a favorite (this coming from someone who would not usually order chicken on pizza!), and they do a great job of the 'ol classic Margherita - LOVE it. The crust is thin but not too thin, and they offer dairy and gluten free option. The salads are also quite good, and to share a salad and pizza between two people for lunch is more than enough food at a reasonable price.
Drink wise they have a great wine selection, and also lots of artisan style soft drinks made right in Canmore (for those who have to go back to work after lunch!).
If I could suggest one spot for improvement, food wise, would be for some olive oil or something to dip the crust in. That would take a good pizza experience and make it divine!
I can't quite give it 5 start (4 1/2 if I could!!) as I have been disappointed by the service a couple of times - just not quite as friendly or welcoming as it should be, but generally efficient.