Everything I've ever had from Sugar has been delicious. It is 3 minute walk from my house so I get to go pretty regularly. It is such a great addition to Dormont!
The staff is always friendly. My only complaint is it gets super busy on the weekend and at times I'm still waiting for a table to eat at by the time my food is ready. But... that means they are doing well so more power to them. I highly recommend the Roasted Turkey Sandwich which is absolutely delicious. I had a special last week, the Chimichurri Chicken Sandwich that was amazing as well. Lots of sweets in the pastry case all the time, and I'm looking forward to the return of the Irish Carbomb Cupcake!!!
I can't say it enough. Go to Sugar Cafe, you won't be disappointed.