I give this review a little more leeway because it was the day of a Browns game, so it was very very busy. Service was kind of slow and we had a hard time getting a table, but it was understandable. It's a cute bar and I'd definitely return on a less busy time. They seem to have great happy hour specials, too.
My bf had fish and chips; he said it was good but not the best ever. The breading on it was not your typical light-colored beer battered look. I got the seafood cobb salad which was excellent. It had yellowfin tuna and shrimp, plus I appreciated that it was a diet-conscious choice. We also got two beers that were $1 off each, so that was a good value.
Overall, the experience wasn't what I would prefer, as it was very loud and full of rowdy football fans, but the food was good. I do agree with some other reviewers that it is a little overpriced, but for a seafood restaurant right downtown, I didn't expect any different.