If this was solely based on going out and having a drink, I would totally give it a 5. But we've got other things to consider!
Atmosphere: loved it! So adorable and cozy and warm. The owner was on the floor seating us. She was so kind and friendly and so Scottish! Very authentic.
Service: unfortunately we got the new girl. As much as she was sweet, she screwed up really bad...over and over and over again. It was rough. They comped 1 appetizer which I didn't think was enough considering the scope of the bad service. Hopefully she gets better! It was a busy night.
Food: the food was ok. Nothing super impressive. The fried pickles were good. The butter chicken was ok. Steak pie was pretty good. The Mac n cheese wasn't quite as awesome as it sounded. So the food wasn't mind blowing.
Drinks: my hubby got the rob Roy. That is a stiiiiiiff drink but he liked it. Not a huge beer selection but enough. They are in fact known for their whiskey selection.
Overall, I would go back for a drink, snacks and the lovely atmosphere.