Came here with the husband for dinner and ordered:
1) Oysters - we ordered the ones from PEI which were delish. The cocktail sauce that came with it was good!
2) Lobster poutine - This was a disappointment. I'm fairly certain that it said on their menu that they used their lobster bisque in the poutine which I thought would be their "gravy" however, the sauce looked like any ole gravy and didn't taste like a lobster bisque. I think the reason why this was a disappointment is that lobster has such a subtle sweet flavour and can be very easily overpowered. When I ate the poutine, all I really tasted was the gravy and the cheese, not so much the lobster. The lobster certainly was not the star of the show.
3) Lobster roll - This was good. Having spent a few years living in the East Coast, this was a good lobster roll. I also liked how they had homemade chips instead of fries on the side and it also came with a big pickle!
4) Lobster mac n cheese - Another disappointment. Same issue as the poutine, the lobster was totally overpowered by the cheese and in fact, my husband felt it was very salty and I felt it was flavourless. We ended up having to ask for pepper to give it some flavour and even that wasn't enough. Perhaps I should have asked for some ketchup...but doesn't that just take away from the fact that I'm supposed to be eating something so decadent? Also, there wasn't a lot of lobster meat compared to the amount of pasta and cheese in the dish.
Service was good - the staff was very attentive.
Overall, I probably wouldn't come back. The prices aren't bad but for a place called "Rock Lobster," you'd expect that the lobster would be the star of the show, unfortunately it was clearly a runner up to everything else.