I travelled nearly an hour to visit The Lobster House because a friend of mine got a TeamBuy voucher for Christmas.
For a really small restaurant located in a strip mall in Pickering, their entrées are quite pricy. I had the cajun salmon with mashed potatoes and vegetables. Each entrée came with an all-you-can-eat salad bar. The salads were quite good, although there was a very limited selection (pasta salad, caesar, and green olives from what I can remember). Each table also receives a loaf of seasoned bread to start. This was also very good. When it came to the entrée, however, I was disappointed to find that the standouts of the dish were the vegetables and the mashed potatoes. Those were mouth-watering - delicious. The cajun salmon was solid, but it just didn't have the standout quality that I expect from a $$$ rated restaurant. Can't give more than 3 stars when the entrée wasn't the best part of the meal!
The service was standard - nothing overly impressive and definitely nothing bad. I'd recommend for people who live in the area to check it out (and to try the lobster, it's probably called The Lobster House for a reason). Give the salmon a shot if you want, but don't expect anything outstanding.