This Pickle Barrel is the go-to location for a lot of night-outs with friends. I've been there over a dozen times in the past couple years and I must be lucky considering the amount of lacklustre reviews from other Yelpers.
The food is alright, considering the long list of dishes on their menu. I've had my share of food I would never order again and ones that I'll keep coming back for.
I love their P.B. House Burger. Pretty common toppings, but they work and I don't see why it needs to be changed. The portion size is good, enough for me to be comfortably full.
Chicken Fingers.... thumbs up.
The P.B. Original Jumbo Club House is something to consider as well. No complaints. Ingredients are nice together.
I suggest passing on the Fried Chicken and Waffles though... I find the taste very monotonous... the Jalapeno Corn waffles just taste like regular waffles... I don't get how those two ingredients enhance the waffle itself. The chicken was fried well, but I found that it was lacking enough seasoning.
Apart from the food, I've found the staff to be quite welcoming - friendly for the most part. That may be just the group I usually go with (We book using the name 'Batman'), but no one's been a downer. Heck, I even got my dinner for free once (after waiting an hour and a half for my food). The waitress was really considerate then, and I haven't forgotten about it since.
Respect and understand your server and you may just get great service too :).