I saw the horrible reviews before I ordered. But my coworkers wanted this for lunch and one promised me it was really good.
However, my experience was not really good food. I ordered the Cajun seasoned broiled Mayflower Platter. It consisted of Fillet of Flounder, Alaskan White Fish Fillet, Sea Scallops, Jumbo Shrimp, & Fried Deviled Crab. The seafood itself was very bland. You could see the Cajun seasoning but there was a serious lack of flavor. It desperately needed salt. Thankfully I had some homemade salad that I could eat it with so that really helped me out. They had a picture of the mayflower platter on their website and my seafood looked nowhere as succulent as theirs did. My shrimp were definitely not Jumbo - even though the description says it. They were more like medium 41/50. What a rip off. The scallops were sweet but small too. The fish fillets were thin and you can tell they were all frozen. Not fresh.
I did try a couple of the hushpuppies and those were not bad at all. And the deviled crab did not taste like crab. I couldn't even see any crab in it. It was just all breading.
I did receive a side salad and steamed broccoli with my platter. I didn't eat the salad since I had my own but when I went to eat it the next day, it was all watery and brown. So that was a no. But the broccoli was cooked well, flavorless but I added salt.
Overall - I would not entertain the idea of eating here again.