Just went here for a date night, and will definitely be coming back when we are in the mood for Italian.
Food: Really reasonable prices for the huge portions of food. The quality of the pasta, tastiness of the sauces, ceasar salad fixings, and homemade bread were all amazing. Shrimp Parmesan gets two thumbs up. Split an appetizer, salad, bread, and entree and took home a full meal for leftovers.
Wine: Selection was okay. Mostly 6/glass and 24/bottle, all Italian. The reds we got were tasty.
Atmosphere: NY stlye pizza counter when you first walk in, then it becomes a quaintly decorated Italian themed place, lighted well and romantic.
Service: Exceptional!!