So much hatred for this place! I though, will always know it as the first place we ate when we visited Madison. It's definitely a hole in the wall, though by the signage all over the place, I could envision it getting pretty busy on the weekends and at night (we went for a mid-week lunch at 2 o'clock in the afternoon).
The food was OK - I had a salad and we tried fried cheese curds for the first time. It's just cheese, apparently, that's been fried. Somehow I had been expecting more. Unfortunately, the service was not great. There were about 4 tables worth of people in there, and it still took forever to get everything.