Webers is hands down my favorite ice cream place. Their custard is absolutely amazing. The seasonal pumpkin is my top pick, although I try to switch it up. If I'm at a loss for what to choose the banana custard is my default.
The people who work here are always nice to me. Ask to try flavors and ask what the person helping you likes - when I tried the PB Oreo and the girl told me it was her favorite. It ended up being what I ordered. Great place!