OMG!!! I lived my this place when it was next to Sunset station for 2 years and never went. Saw the coupon in the Entertainment Book and contemplated on going. Still never went.
Then one day, I'm driving down Eastern on my way to work and lo and behold they reopened and my curiosity was piqued again! Still didn't go despite my interested because where it's located, the parking lot is always full, so that was the major turnoff.
I finally decided to go when I went out to dinner with my friend Monette and she had mentioned that she had it before and raved about it. Knowing someone else went made me finally try it. When I got there it was pretty crowded but the "custard people" were pretty quick and very accommodating. I stepped aside to check out the menu and I ended up just getting plain vanilla but I added malt to it and let me tell you...it was was creamy as gelato!! I've had frozen custard before and a huge fan of it so I was a bit doubtful before I tasted it. Upon scraping the bottom of my little bowl and licking the last of my taste of heaven, the doubts were gone.
It's right in between Grimaldi's and Cafe Rio so a lot of people have their dessert at Sheridan's so it does look crowded but like I mentioned earlier, the service was quick. They are a bit pricey (think Cold Stone Creamery prices) but it would be a cute place to take a date or on a really hot day (like in the days to come!! helloooo summer!!) that I believe is worth visiting and trying. If you like creamy textures of cold delicious yumminess, this is the place to try!