So... I'm slightly addicted to Mitchell's ice cream. I have been to this location multiple times either to have a scoop of ice cream at the shop or to buy some to take home. I honestly cannot think of a flavor that I've had here that I didn't love. Some of my current favorites for the summer are Campfire Smores and Key Lime Pie. Since the flavors change seasonally, if you like a flavor make sure to enjoy it before it's out of rotation.
Tip: you can buy a pint here at the Mitchell's location or at some local grocery stores for the same price (5.99). HOWEVER... when you buy a pint here, it comes with 3 free cones, so you can make your own little ice cream cones at home.