I come here for the oysters and a cadillac margarita. And it is awesome, every time.
They have possibly the best oysters in Phoenix (shhh!). The kids gets fish and chips when we visit, and from what i've sampled, that is good too. As for the rest of the menu? Who knows. The options are plentiful, but nothing inspires me to stray from my usual.
For whatever reason this place is not very popular, which means you can get a nice booth to yourself. Steep prices, location, or fade-into-the-background vibe could be a factor for keeping others away... but personally, I like that it isn't too crowded. Sometimes you want a spot to get away from noise and this fits the bill.