First off I'd like to say the ambiance here is fantastic! Having a split Bar and Restaurant is a great way to keep you from the bar people, and the bar people from you. I would love to say that I enjoyed my visit here even more, but unfortunately it seems the food I selected was not the best meal to order here.
I suppose my first clue should have been that the steak sandwich I ordered was delivered with a bottle of Ketchup. The sandwich was a sad strip of steak with two sad tomatoes and a bit of Lettuce. I opted instead for a bottle of A-1, which was promptly provided. Certainly not the best Steak Sandwich I've ever had, and I would not order it again if I returned. The Onion Rings though, were a different story, they were very very good and really probably saved the review from a lower rating.
I was with a rather large party and our waitress was quite attentive, so service does not appear to be a problem. Everyone else seemed to really enjoy their food, so perhaps the issue is more with that menu item and less with the place in general.