Went here during the winter because it's never too cold to have some ice cream. A waffle cone with two scoops goes for $5, but well worth it. Please trust me and get the waffle cone over the boring sugar and wafer cones! It was probably the best waffle cone I've ever had and it comes with a little m&m at the bottom to catch the leakage.
Birthday Cake: Had I discovered this sooner, I would have just asked for an ice cream cake with this flavor instead of getting the ones from Carvel every year. It comes with sprinkles, bits of cake, and frosting --so delicious.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough: Usually I don't go for this flavor but it is really good and one scoop has a ton of cookie dough.
Coconut Cream Pie: Very creamy with bits of pie crust and coconut flakes.
Dave & Andy's is a great ice cream shop to go to, since everything is homemade and super yummy!