This place is hit or miss, and seems to be a miss recently.
I came here last summer and had an ok meal. A bit overpriced for just OK Italian food, but still had a nice dinner.
The atmosphere is rather inviting and the ambiance is nice. If you're into stuff like that, try hitting it up for lunch or a few drinks. I would say the dinner is definitely not worth the price.
We tried to go back last weekend and were told that there was a 15 minute wait, while we could easily see that the dining room had at least half of the tables open. I understand reservations, but I find it hard to believe that 8+ tables were all coming within the next 15 minutes. It also took awhile to even find a host (I think he was a waiter too?).
Madison seems to be in need of a niche upscale Italian restaurant. Hopefully Food Fight pulls through for us with their new opening on State Street.