I've been here a handful of times.
1st time was only for drinks and it was really good. They have a lot of local beers on tap and the bar tenders know the beers well
2nd time, I got a bit adventurous and decided to order a meal along with beers. The items sounded really good on the menu and I was excited to try it. I ordered a fried chicken sandwich and was soon very disappointed. The chicken was rock solid. It was over battered and over fried. After barely keeping my teeth in my mouth from biting through the sandwich, I decided to never order food from here again. My wife had a similar experience with her meal as well (very nice description on the menu, very underwhelming in front of her).
I've Returned here for drinks only a few more times and worked up to ordering a side of fries. The portion was good and fried nicely.
Atmosphere: 5 star.
Drinks : 5 star
Food. Maybe 2.5 stars. I'm still a bit scared to try a whole meal here again.
I really want to give them a 5 star, but I still have my reservations.