If I still went to McGill I'd be here all the time... I think. The filter coffee was fresh, and served quick - nice to see a light, buttery, bright "third wave" roast served fast and without pretension. The muffin I had was super fresh and... creamy? almost? it was so moist and good. The owner was there jumping in to tell me about the coffee they were serving, to make sure I knew when the muffins had been made, to say a friendly goodbye, and all this helped counterbalance the gal barista behind the counter talking loudly about how she had been scouted by Paris cafes to go teach them how to proprerly make coffee. Le sigh.
Love the thoughtful decor, especially the study-friendly touches like the well-placed outlets. I'd have been happier if they had cream as well as milk, call me indulgent if you must. I dunno, I'm torn between 3 and 4 stars but feeling appreciative and generous and hoping they'll survive and thrive. Some off notes of coffee snob weirdness aside, Humble Lion is an excellent option in the neighbourhood.