They get A for effort, C+ for execution.
They're a solid place with decent seafood. But the prawn linguine was drowning in butter and tasted like nothing else. The scallops and mahi mahi had a nice crust and was cooked well. But the polenta/risotto cake was also heavily buttered.
I would stick with just seafood in the simplest possible way. The prices are decent, not overpriced and the service is great.