This is bordering on being a one but the friendliness of the waitress and the layout bumps it up a bit.
I tried cheese curds (basic recipe so it was alright) and their ribs with potatoe and pasta salad. Also their blue cheese burger. The ribs were tough and a bit dry and the burger was a travesty. The burger was hard to describe, although it didn't seem to be underseasoned, all the flavors just blurred togeather into some strange old hamburger type taste. Very strange. The salads were ok but not my favorite. Finally the bbq sauces are very tomatoey which is not my style.
On the bright side though, I really really really liked their fries. They seemed house made and although I wouldn't recommend the dishes I tried, a plate of their fries would be nice to have.
As always though, you'll only know if you like it if you go there yourself and give the nice folks a shot. They have tvs and such so maybe try it out for one of the badgers bball games.