I have had Mr. Tokyo bookmarked for some time now. I purposely haven't visited because I was afraid my fear would come to fruition, which it did. Sure, all you can eat sounds great! But the quality was not all the good.
I went with the all you can eat for $18 this past Saturday. I started with the miso soup. The soup had more broth than seaweed and tofu; very disappointing. Then I went with the hibachi of shrimp and vegetables, no rice. If you eat traditional hibachi, you know that fresh off the grill taste... well that was missing. The shrimp were also very small and were over cooked. The hibachi tasted like it was lightly pan fried with a teaspoon of soy sauce poured in. Lastly the nigiri and sushi... not good quality at all to me. If I had a California roll, I understand it wouldn't be all that but there's no reason why the specialty rolls are not great. There as no fresh taste and some of the rolls with crab were frozen.
I will say the place has a really nice ambience on the inside and the service was spectacular. But, there are literally dozens of other places to eat if you prefer quality over quantity.