My husband Rick wanted ice cream last night after dinner. So we took a walk over here. I've avoided this place. See, to me there's something about places whose names end in "...ery". "...ery"= $$$! Honestly, what can you get here that you can't get at Baskin Robbins or, even better, Bruster's for a whole lot less $$$? Or as Ryan P suggests, try "Oh Yeah!" in Shadyside (but I haven't been there in awhile).
The other thing I hate about places like Cold Stone Creamery is that the portions have gotten insanely huge. I have type-1 diabetes, and while I can eat ice cream (and modify my insulin and carb intake), the sizes here are just carb bombs! I only go to places like this if I can share with someone.
To its credit, Cold Stone Creamery does list "healthier" options http://www.coldstonecreamery.com/icecream/healthy_indulgences.html While I think the ice cream here is okay, you can get just as good for less $$ elsewhere.