I really wanted to love this place. I really did.
Madison has so many good steakhouses, and I was hoping this would be able to break into my normal rotation. However, the meal was just mediocre.
We had two appetizers, the bbq prawns and the stuffed mushrooms. The mushrooms lacked flavor. The prawns were good size and had a good flavor. I would recommend those as a good option.
I ordered the ribeye, which is my favorite cut and what I get everywhere I go. My fiance ordered the filet. Both were cooked very well, but the flavor was just missing something. It lacked the melt-in-your-mouth, ohmyfreakinggod experience of Delaney's or Tornado. Overall both steaks were adequate.
For sides, definitely go with the hashbrowns, they were far and away the highlight of the meal. double baked potato was bland.
Price is one thing this place has going for it, because their steaks come with a soup or salad and side dish included.
Overall, I find it hard to say I will ever come back to this place with so many great steak options in Madison. Just didn't do enough to put it in the same discussion with the best this city has to offer.