This place isn't as bad as all of these negative reviews claim..
I'm local and was very anxious to try their edible cookie dough. I wasn't that impressed with it, the taste wasn't horrible it just tasted like it had been sitting there for a while. I sampled all three flavors (choc. chip, peanut butter and jelly, & butter pecan) I went with a half scoop of chocolate chip because their full scoop is much larger than your typical scoop and would have been way too much to consume in my opinion. I also got a scoop of butter pecan in a cone.
They get an extra star because the staff was incredibly helpful on offering samples and their opinions on flavors, etc..
Their prices weren't as horrible as I'm reading they are but that's probably because I'm used to Vegas prices. I wouldn't go out of my way to come back but if I was ever inside of Treasure Island and craving something sweet, I'd return!