2nd Update: I'm subtracting yet another star for being out of my first three beer choices.
1st Update: I'm subtracting two stars from my earlier Ceili rating. I was there again last night and experienced some of the surly and inflexible service that others mention in their reviews. We were one person too many for the table we had gatherer around, and the staff seemed to determined to ensure that we would remain short one chair. A piano bench sat empty and within arms reach, but we were admonished when we tried to claim it for our use - because someone may want to play piano.
I tried to explain that we could swap a chair for the stool so that the piano would remain playable, but they were determined to ignore that logic. Within a few minutes, someone else was sitting at the piano and using it only as a beer rest.
I give the food a four, the bar a five and the overall experience a three. It's funny how one moment of bad service is all it takes to cause a reviewer to subtract two stars and entirely delete their earlier, unabashedly glowing review.