Came for Winterlicious. Everything was okay, but it didn't live up to the hype.
Food 3/5: For my app I had the oyster rockefeller, which was a bit too salty. My main was the Peter Street Fish which was luke warm by the time it hit the table and the fish had clearly been frozen, however the sauce it was covered with was quite good. For dessert I had the pecan pie which was cold, it would have been a lot better if they'd heated it up. Although I was pretty disappointed by the food, I'm hoping its just the winterlicious curse and I will come back because they had some pretty good deals (ie. half price apps at happy hour and shuck-for-a-buck Mondays). I ordered the piquant shrimp while waiting for my friend and this was better than any of the winterlicious food. The shrimp sauce was tangy and spicy (although the shrimp did have that frozen texture) and the hushpuppies it came with were fried to perfection. The portion was super small and it wasn't worth $12, but at half price it was great!
Atmosphere 4/5: The only way I can describe this place is so tacky its cute.