Definitely sad to see Sole no longer occupying this spot (best tres leches of all time) but definitely wanted to give Italian Pie a shot.
We ordered a small pizza and a calzone. The pizza was really good, the calzone was just so-so.
Beer specials were good - decent price - but they didn't have/feature any italian beers, which was a little disappointing.
The decor, honestly, is a step backward from what it was with Sole, and frankly that hurt my overall scoring. I would definitely go to this place if you live close enough for a pizza run - the pie was good!