Went last night for supper and this seems like the place that my parents always bring out of town visitors, I guess because it is so fancy and the food there is incredible.
I would say this is one of the best all you can eat places in town. It is a bit more expensive but you are paying for service as well, and I find Cynthia's has a larger selection than all of the all you can eat places in Newmarket. The good thing about Cynthia's is that the portions do come in smaller sizes, so that way you don't ever make that common mistake at ordering too much at an all you can eat and end up wasting so much food.
The service was really good, half way through our dinner our server replaced all our dirty plates with new ones so that was a first !
Will definitely one of my favorite sushi restaurants in Newmarket, Cynthia and her staff never disappoints