If ice cream has an MVP.. a GOAT .. an All American representative.. it would be McMahon's Ice Cream.
Right off the "bat" the customer service is great. You're greeted by staff and encouraged to try the flavors and it is all done with a smile.
You'll have a wide variety of selections to choose from: horchata, the HULK, peach cobbler, cookies and cream and chocolate chip cookie dough. The latter has huge chunks of cookie dough. Unlike other competitors where you get a small ball of dough, McMahon's has HUGE chunks that really make the flavor a "touchdown."
Prices are reasonable for the portion size. I get a kick to see the employees really use their elbows and muscles to dig out generous portions for their customers. I watched one employee glaze on a layer of chocolate fudge for a person ahead of me... and it was covered!! Just like the person wanted. They really do want you to leave satisfied and in a ice cream coma.
It will be difficult for any other business to beat McMahons. We have gone multiple times as a late night treat and have tried multiple flavors: they're all great. I am not a fan or sorbet, but I really enjoyed their lemon sorbet. It tastes just like a summer should!
Give this place a try, you won't regret it.