first time I ordered was because of the awesome deal with the coupon taped to my door as well ...
however I have continued going back for the big buffalo chicken pizza!! I don't even like spicy but this pizza is AWESOME! I don't know what they put in this that makes it so amazing but I cannot stop!
I usually pick up my pizza because it's so close to my house and it's always neat and clean inside. I have had delivery (in the past) several times by mafia mikes and once the driver must have dropped the pizza or something because it was an absolute mess when we opened the box ... I called to complain and they promptly made us another pizza (which we picked up) I thought it a little rude the driver didn't say anything and we even brought the messy pizza in to show them and the guy at the counter apologized and let us keep the messed up one and gave us a fresh one free of charge.
My only complaint is that I pay $20 for a large big buffalo .... a little pricy if you ask me ... especially when their competitors are offering 2 mediums for $6.99/each or larges at $10 a piece ... The best mafia mikes does is a large pepperoni for like $10 I think
But they have me hooked and I do fork over $20 for the big buffalo because it is soooooooo worth it.