1) They have very good pizza. The pizzas are large, delicious, and re-heat well (you will have leftovers if you get a large for 2 people)
2) They have a great beer list, though it seems like they are always out of whatever I want. A lot of craft beer on tap, and a lot more in bottles. Excellent.
3) The service is usually pretty good and it's a fun place to go with a few friends.
I've never tried a sandwich or anything but their pizza, but then again, why would I? If it wasn't for the debacle that is parking on or near Ellsworth on a weekend night, I'd go here more regularly.