(Decided to give this place a second shot. Owner reached out to me and genuinely wanted to make reparations for my bad experience last visit. I'm glad I did.
Ordered a 1 lb burger, and oh man. I had to bite once on top, and once on bottom. They loaded my burger UP! Had the cheese curd appetizer. REALLY good with the Chipotle aioli sauce. Girlfriend had the lamb burger, and wouldn't stop telling me how delicious it was, she actually wants to try making it at home... and she's never even had lamb.
Now last time i was here i had the onion rings... and was disappointed. This time... they literally melted in your mouth. The onion didn't slide out of the batter, nor was it overcooked. Utter perfection.
If they can maintain this level all the time, then i highly recommend coming here.