I should give this 2.5 stars - the beginning (pesto with the bread) and the end (dessert) were terrific. What came between was adequate at best. Given the prices I expected to get better quality than the Olive Garden, but it was only marginally better...
I had fried calamari and the scallop main course, my wife had the pizza app and bucatini main course. My calamari was heavily breaded and rubbery - it had to be frozen food service calamari or frozen from a bad like you'd get at Safeway. It couldn't have been fresh. The scallops were tasty, but over salted and very small - not the very large sea scallops I'm used to in quality restaurants.
My wife's pizza was really good - thin crispy crust and very nicely done. Her bucatini was too peppery and tasted like it was a sauce from a jar.
The highlight was dessert - the tiramisu and toffee chocolate cake were great! They were probably bought in too (do they make anything in house?) but they were really good!
So if we went back I guess it would be for pizza and dessert. Otherwise I'd save your money and go to the Wynn Buffet, Red8 or Il Mulino if you want Italian.