The last time my brother and I were in town we wanted to do a "man's day", which involved a hot shave, good steak dinner and, of course, a good cigar to finish it off. Our quest for a good cigar led us here.
Mind you, I'm not a cigar aficionado by any stretch, but I do enjoy a good smoke every now and then. We let our bartender (totally forgot his name) know what we were after, and he pointed us in the right direction both times. Over the course of the two cigars we went through three glasses of bourbon as well.
The prices are sure spendy, but the atmosphere was spot on. The waitress were all attractive and friendly. The humidor was huge. The only nit to pick was the fact that the bartender measured each shot of whiskey, but that's really reaching for something to complain about.
If you're into cigars (or even if you're not) you owe it to yourself to visit.