Amid a delightful neighborhood filled with nice sit-down restaurants lies Presti's. This is the holy grail of "take a number and wait in line".
Family run, Presti's offers a full range of baked goods, italian fare, espresso drinks, and even gelato! They always have different foods made fresh in the display ripe for the ordering. If the crowds are any indication of popularity, then they might be Regina George without the attitude.
My only advice is get there early unless you want a long line!