I've been to Tavern Square Dominion many times and I've always had a great experience. Balsam Inn, on the other hand, was disappointing.
I ordered a soup of the day, which was bland and salty, and the penne à la Norma. It was an odd combination of eggplant and tomatoes, the sauce was oily and the dish was pretty unflavorful.
The only redeeming quality of the place is the decor and service.