I'm vexed and haunted by how consistently good each cup of gelato I've gotten from here is. The flavor descriptions sound incredible on their own and Messina hits it home by making their gelati with ingredients and mix-ins that make each spoonful so dreamy. I've been a fan of their rotating special flavor selection, but Panna Cotta with Fig Jam and Amaretti has a special place in my heart and continues to be my favorite $3.50 scoop.