Would have been 4 stars but the server was really pushy.
They have two evening sittings. 6pm and 8pm. Our reservations were at 6.
Once my wife and I got there for a table of 10, the server immediately asked us to order. Since I was hosting for my out of town relatives I wanted them to look at the menu to see if there was anything they wanted to try instead of the set meals.
The server kept trying to up-sell the menu and recommended us to order for the 10 people set menu, when I had two toddlers with me!
Food came out quickly and every one enjoyed their meal. The food is great, see everyone's comments below.
At the end of the evening when I got the bill they tried to sell the fact that tips were not included, I also did not appreciate that. I always tip and did not like that.
Although the food was great the service was somewhat sub par and aggravating at the start and end.
Notes:
Cash only, reservations required, make sure your lobster isn't over sized, if so you'll get charged extra.