I took my car to Mike's auto body as it's recommended by Geico and is part of their easy claims and repair process. This was a big mistake. Like many of the reviewers here, I was initially told it would take a certain amount of time, and then, at the last minute, on the day I was supposed to get my car back, they told me it would be a few more days. Their excuse? The headlamp that came in didn't have a bulb with it. Seriously? Since this was the Geico rep telling me this I couldn't really argue, but I don't know why Geico keeps working with a business that repeatedly does this to its customers.
I got the car back in great condition, cleaned on the outside, and the console wiped down inside. All in all, just alright - go here if you're not pressed for time and you've got Geico, otherwise shop around.