The reviews for The Pickle Barrel are mixed so you can really only visit this restaurant with a positive, open mind.
Personally, I liked my experience. We were seated promptly, the customer service was good, everything arrived in good time. The food tasted good! Not "to die for" but good.
Criticisms that I have: the portions were either too small or the serving plates were too big, on both appetizers and meals.. There was a lot of empty space. The menu was too big, there were like 12 pages of so many incredible choices that it was difficult to read everything. The restaurant layout was totally weird but who really cares.
I can suggest going on a Thursday night, because it was relatively empty when I went. Be prepared to spend at least 50 bucks for two people. Best of luck!