Don't judge a book by its cover! Sure you're getting a gyro in a gas station but who cares? Athens Gyros is hands down the best gyros in the Madison area....yes better than the Parthenon. A lot better.
The tzatziki sauce and meat are fresh and made on site. The pitas are always warm and soft but not chewy like some.
The seating area is small but always clean and well maintained. There are plenty of high chairs for your little gyro eaters and the bathrooms are clean.
BONUS: Since it's in a gas station, you can basically get any kind of drink you'd like!
We live 25 minutes from Athens Gyros but we regularly make the drive!