I found the Olde Stone Cottage on a blog about the Top 10 pubs in Scarborough, so I decided to check it out. Parking is limited - luckily I managed to find a spot at the far end of the parking lot.
We had no issues being seated and were seated promptly. The atmosphere was cozy. They had a live musician as well, but i had to yell to be heard by my companions. However, I don't think that this is atypical as other pubs have the same.
I ordered the bacon mac and cheese as this is supposed to be one of their popular dishes. I didn't have to wait long before it was brought over to our table. It was quite tasty - hot, gooey with cheese sauce and yummy bacon.
Overall, it was a good experience. But I don't believe it was far above the other pubs in Scarborough that I've been to. If I'm in the area, sure, I'd check it out again. But I wouldn't purposely make the trek out here as there are other decent pubs closer to home.