Smallman Street Deli is *the* deli in Squirrel Hill. Everything here is good. The chalkboard menu is a bit intimidating because there are just SO MANY choices. I got the baked ham and Havarti cheese on Bolki roll, which came with a pickle slice, and hugged it up with a bottled black cherry soda. Everything was fresh and tasty!
Only reason it doesn't get 5/5 is because I've been to delis in NYC and well, that's where 5/5 lives.