I stopped in in the afternoon (maybe around 4?) and the selection was very slim, so I ended up going with the 2 basics--vanilla, and the tuxedo (chocolate with vanilla frosting). My husband had the vanilla and said it was ok. I had the tuxedo...honestly, it tasted like it was made from a cheap boxed cake mix--Not that the boxed mixes taste bad, but for $3.50 each, I want better than box. My husband didn't mention the moistness of the vanilla one, but the tuxedo one was way too moist--like falling apart while I was trying to eat it. I ended up throwing half of it away because it was getting too messy and just wasn't that good. My suggestion, drive a few more minutes down Scottsdale Rd. and go to Sprinkles.