I'm not particularly offended, but I'm definitely not impressed. I'd say a solid 2.5 stars.
The setting is kind of a mix of quaint meets nice meets tacky. I really don't want to be rude, but the artwork on the walls they had was just really unappealing. I know that beauty is in the eye of the beholder but it really clashed with the rest of the decor. Everything seemed to have a layer of filth over it, our booth and table were sticky and there was crud all within the cracks of the wood. Even our menus were covered with spilled sauce. Turned me off a lot to the place.
The food was mediocre. Nothing to complain about, nothing to write home about. We got the grilled chicken tenders which were okay, the Tremonster (which I stole a bite of - it was okay), and I had the Cobb salad. The salad was pretty good, the guac was delicious and the black pepper dressing was equally good.
The have a decent sized beer list, but none of them are anything special, or anything I would go out of my way to have outside of being there.
Our server was friendly and polite. He (or the kitchen) did get my order wrong but he was very quick in correcting it!
I'll definitely never go out of my way to come back. I won't put up a fight if I were invited here as part of a group outing, but I'd suggest another place before accepting the invite.