We went into the Codfather after hearing all the positive vibe and came away...satisfied.
The atmosphere was perfect for us. I love the look and feel of a good English pub, and while the location is a little worse for wear, it was just fine.
We had the fried mushrooms and zucchini as appetizers and I gotta say: really damn good. The garlic breading on those were amazing.
For meals we had the cod and the crab legs. The cod was admittedly just okay; if they used the same garlic breading, it would probably be amazing, but their normal beer batter was rather flavorless. The crab legs were fantastic, though.
The service was quite good, which definitely helped raise my score from 3 stars to 4. In all, we'll be back, but next time, we'll look at some shepherd's pie!