I like the cozy, home-style atmosphere.
I like the cashier's charming, inviting attitude.
I like the options for toppings.
I like the dessert selection.
I like your prices.
But I just can't get into your pizza. Maybe it's my fault for ordering by the slice, and not a whole pie. I'm not expecting the freshest product, but I think mine was reheated more than once. Even individual servings shouldn't have rock-hard crust or visibly burnt edges. I understand that this place has a lot of heart, and for that I'm sure I'll give it another try for something beyond pizza, which I am a snob about. Had it been in pristine condition, IDK what about it would jump out. For now, it's a mystery why my friends are giving it nothing but 4+ stars.